image

Directors and Officers Insurance Recovery

Overview

Disappointed investors or employees sue corporations and their directors and officers for tumbling stock prices or employment-related claims with more frequency. Insurance companies sell more complex insurance products to defray their risk associated with these lawsuits. Anderson Kill, named by Chambers USA as one of the nation’s top law firms nationally for insurance dispute resolution, represents D&O policyholders in disputes with insurance companies.

Our comprehensive experience upholding and advancing policyholders’ rights in Directors & Officers insurance coverage includes A-Side Coverage and B-Side Coverage, Employment Practices Liability, and Entity Securities Coverage. We have faced the complex disputes involving contentious issues such as right to select counsel and defense costs, definition of claim and loss, punitive or exemplary damages, and the litany of exclusions. We handle claims in bankruptcy proceedings. We address allocation issues in addition to the many other issues raised by insurance companies and faced by directors and officers in insurance disputes.

Anderson Kill knows insurance coverage inside and out. We put our far-reaching experience and thorough historical database of knowledge to work for our clients with incisive scrutiny. Our approach is to analyze our clients’ case and put a tailored strategy before the court. With our experience handling hundreds of significant insurance recovery cases, we can anticipate arguments and obtain favorable settlements and decisions for our clients.

Experience

    • Eric Spiel (former officer of Modell’s Sporting Goods). Anderson Kill represents Eric Spiel in pursuit of ongoing D&O coverage and to defend him against claims that the D&O insurance company should be required to reimburse the plaintiff for amounts paid to Mr. Spiel. The plaintiff in Modell v. Argonaut Insurance Company and Eric Spiel (SDNY), a policyholder covered under the same D&O policy as the one covering Mr. Spiel, alleges that Mr. Spiel breached a provision in their shared D&O policy. The insurance company joins Mr. Spiel in arguing that Modell’s claim is baseless, that no breach occurred, and that moreover Modell has no standing to assert that the insurance company should deny coverage to another policyholder. Mr. Spiel and Argonaut have both filed motions to dismiss the Modell claim for failure to state a cause of action.  This motion is currently pending before the court.

 

  • Benefytt Technologies, Inc. In a suit filed in Delaware state court in February 2021, Benefytt seeks to secure D&O and E&O protection for 3 underlying claims for a securities class action defense, a consumer class action defense and indemnification, and repayment of defense costs and statutory market conduct examination claim expenses. This coverage litigation implicates two lines of liability insurance coverage. The dispute also involves arguments by certain insurance companies over related claims defenses involving claim placement from policy period to policy period, late notice arguments, notice of wrongful acts, and recoupment claims. To date we have secured over $21 million in coverage settlements, and the litigation remains pending. Trial will likely take place in 2024.

 

COMPLETED CASES

Anderson Kill represents enterprise resource and supply chain management software provider QAD regarding Directors & Officers liability insurance coverage, including defense costs and indemnity payments, for the company and the company’s directors arising out of the securities litigation entitled Nantahala Capital Partners II Limited Partnership v. QAD et al., in the Court of Chancery of the State of Delaware. Following a series of mediations, Anderson Kill was able to negotiate a favorable settlement for QAD and its directors and officers, the terms of which settlement is confidential.

Anderson Kill filed an insurance coverage action on behalf of Crestview against its Directors and Officers insurance companies to recover over $36 million in defense costs incurred by Crestview in defending litigation filed against Crestview, Crestview’s principals, and Crestview’s affiliates by William Koch, his company Oxbow Carbon LLC and Koch’s affiliates. The insurance companies have asserted that there is only coverage for $3.5 million of Crestview’s defense costs based on, among other things, various policy exclusions, including the breach of contract exclusion, and the insurance companies’ assertion that the policies do not cover the cost of litigating counterclaims. In July 2021, in an important ruling concerning discovery, the New York Supreme Court held that attorney-client privilege and work product protect communications between the policyholder and its insurance broker and that the privilege can even apply to internal communications prepared in anticipation of litigation. Policyholders frequently rely on their insurance broker for advice concerning insurance claims and need to protect those communications from discovery. The claim was settled after February 2022. The scope of the breach of contract exclusion is a frequently litigated issue that is often raised in private company D&O insurance disputes, as is the counterclaim coverage issue.

Represented policyholder to recover D&O liability insurance on account of civil and criminal antitrust claims.

Represented policyholder to recover D&O liability insurance and prevent rescission action.

Federal Ins. Co. v. Kozlowski, 18 A.D.3d 33, 792 N.Y.S.2d 397 (1st Dep’t 2005).

Princeton University – summary judgment as to liability in D&O case. Trustees of Princeton University v. National Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, PA., 83 N.Y.S.2d 437, appeal dismissed, 11 N.Y.3d 847 (Nov. 24, 2008)

WebMd Health — summary judgment to advance defense costs in D&O case.

HLTH Corp. v. Agricultural Exc. & Sur. Ins. Co., 2008 WL 3413327 (2008), appeal as to certain insurance companies Axis Reinsurance Co. v. HLTH Corp., No. 565, 2009 (2010). Final insurance company, New Hampshire Insurance Company, withdrew “recoupment” claim (2013).

Events

Directors & Officers / Errors & Omissions

Society of Risk Management Consultants (SRMC) Fall 2025 Conference / October 23, 2025

Executive Liability – The Changing Risks of Leadership

RIMS Oregon Chapter / June 4, 2025

Current Issues in D&O Liability Insurance (SRMC 2024)

Society of Risk Management Consultants (SRMC) Fall 2024 Conference / October 24, 2024

Environmental Insurance Coverage Under CGL, Property, and D&O Policies for PFASs, ESG, NRS, CERCLA, RCRA, OPA, and Others (2023)

Strafford Publications / October 3, 2023

Do You Want to Get the Deal Done? Obstacles and Opportunities in Contract Negotiation

RIMS Canada Conference 2023 / September 14, 2023

Update on U.S. Securities Litigation and Coverage Considerations

New York City Bar / June 17, 2022

COVID-19, ESG, and SPACs, Oh My!: Emerging D&O Liabilities

RIMS ERM Conference / November 11, 2021

Anderson Kill’s 15th Annual D&O Conference “D&O Insurance in the Era of Technological and Enforcement Uncertainty”

Anderson Kill / June 8, 2017

Recent Developments Regarding the “Disgorgement” Defense in D&O and E&O Liability Insurance Claims

Society of Risk Management Consultants / October 27, 2016

D&O Strategies – Be Smart, Be Aware

RIMS Massachusetts Chapter / November 19, 2015

Everything a Risk Manager Needs to Know About D&O Liability and Insurance

RIMS PERK Tampa Bay Chapter / October 21, 2015

What you need to D-and-Know about Directors and Officers Insurance

Anderson Kill's 12th Annual D&O Conference / March 12, 2015

Publications

Climate Change, ESG, And D&O Insurance: Collision Or Cooperation?

Journal of Emerging Issues in Litigation / February 25, 2022

Claims Related To Special Purpose Acquisition Company And D&O Insurance Face Increased Insurer Scrutiny

American Bar Association (ABA) / September 30, 2021

Spacs, COVID-19, And ESG, Oh My! — What’s A Director To Do?

National Association of Corporate Directors (NACD) / July 25, 2021

Viewpoint: Due Process, Bill Cosby, And D&O Liability Insurance Conduct Exclusions

Claims Journal / July 8, 2021

The Year Of Peak Spac? The Spac Gold Rush And Implications For D&O Liability And Insurance

New York Law Journal (NYLJ) / May 21, 2021

Anticipating Coronavirus D&O Insurance Claims

Risk Management Magazine / April 17, 2020

NJ Cos. May Have Insurance Coverage For COVID-19 Losses

Law 360 / March 20, 2020

DELAWARE COURT STRENGTHENS APPLICABILITY OF ‘LARGER SETTLEMENT RULE’ TO D&O ALLOCATION DISPUTES DESPITE ‘RELATIVE LEGAL EXPOSURE’ POLICY PROVISION

Policyholder Advisor & Alert / February 18, 2020

D&O Liability Insurance: What Will Impact Be Of A Kinder Gentler Corporation?

New York Law Journal (NYLJ) / October 15, 2019

D&O Policy ‘Bankruptcy Exclusion’ Held To Be An Unenforceable ‘Ipso Facto’ Clause

New York Law Journal (NYLJ) / September 23, 2019

How Changing Corporate Purpose May Affect D&O Insurance

Law360 / August 28, 2019

MIND YOUR D’S AND O’S (INSURANCE): PROTECTING THE BOARD FROM EXECUTIVE CYBER RISK

Policyholder Advisor & Alert / July 29, 2019

D&O Liability: Looking Back At 2018 & Ahead To 2019

PropertyCasualty360 / January 2, 2019

5 Things To Know About Transaction Liability Insurance

Property Casualty 360 / July 9, 2018

D&O INSURANCE FOR CRYPTOCURRENCY LITIGATION

Policyholder Advisor & Alert / February 15, 2018

10 TRAPS IN YOUR D&O INSURANCE

Policyholder Advisor & Alert / June 29, 2015

News

An Agreement to Agree to Allocate Is Not an Allocation Method: Anderson Kill Secures Delaware Superior Court Decision Reaffirming Larger Settlement Rule Allocation Method

July 10, 2026

$95M Kaiser Row Tees Up Challenge For Fund Returns

February 26, 2026

Insurance Pros Size Up Top D&O Risks At NYC Conference

February 26, 2026

Insurance Industry Still On Alert After Tariff Ruling

February 26, 2026

Jorge R. Aviles Joins Anderson Kill’s Insurance Recovery Practice in D.C. as a Shareholder

August 27, 2025

Paramount Executives Ask: Could They Be Sued for Settling Trump’s $20 Billion CBS Lawsuit?

February 15, 2025

Trump Win Shakes Up D&O Coverage Risks Across Sectors

November 7, 2024

Former Modell’s CEO Loses Insurance Row Over Officer Legal Costs

February 9, 2024

Banking Crisis Has Implications for D&O Insurance Sector

March 21, 2023

Crypto Winter Raises Host of D&O Coverage Issues

February 10, 2023

Executive Risks Grow As SEC Climate Disclosure Rules Evolve

February 1, 2023

Cyber, Crypto Top D&O Concerns as Fears Over SPAC Claims Ease

February 1, 2023

D&O Insurance Cases to Watch in 2023

January 2, 2023

Businesses advised to review D&O, other policies for ESG risk

December 8, 2022

D&O Coverage Offers Layered Protection In Bankruptcy

September 21, 2022

D&O Insurance Cases To Watch In 2022

January 3, 2022

Anderson Kill Shareholder Raymond A. Mascia Jr. Named a Rising Star in Insurance by Law360

July 7, 2020

D&O, Employment Practices Insurers Sing the Varsity Blues

May 7, 2019

Anderson Kill Insurance Recovery Attorneys to Speak at RIMS 2019

April 4, 2019

Tips for Executives To Maximize D&O Coverage

June 27, 2016

Environmental responsibility is latest front in D&O litigation

June 6, 2015

Lawyers Weigh In On High Court’s Omnicare Decision

March 24, 2015

Insurance MVP: Anderson Kill’s William Passannante

December 4, 2013

People

image
Cameron R. Argetsinger

Shareholder , Washington, DC

image
image
Diana Shafter Gliedman

Shareholder , New York

image
image
Cort T. Malone

Shareholder , New York, Shelton

image
image
Raymond A. Mascia Jr.

Shareholder , New York

image
image
Seán McCabe

Attorney , New York

image
image
William G. Passannante

Shareholder , New York

image
Key Contact(s)
image
William G. Passannante
View Moreimage

© Copyright 2026 by Anderson Kill P.C. ClickySoft - WordPress Development Company