image

Construction and Insurance Disputes

Overview

Anderson Kill brings together talented attorneys from several allied fields to provide legal counsel and representation for both construction and insurance-related issues. We also handle restructurings, reorganizations and workouts, and provide risk management analysis. Dispute resolution services include advice about how to avoid litigation. Where disputes are necessary or inevitable, we provide representation in arbitration, mediation, and litigation in court, whether it is a construction dispute or an insurance coverage dispute, or both. Indeed, the “both” is what distinguishes Anderson Kill from others.

Construction Disputes

Property owners/developers, contractors, and other project participants, including design professionals, have all benefited from the experience and skill that Anderson Kill attorneys bring to resolving construction disputes. In construction, the main focus must always be on completing the job in a timely manner, and with as few lingering disputes as possible. With that focus in mind, Anderson Kill works in harmony with the overriding business priorities of its clients. Where construction disputes cannot be resolved informally, by settlement, or other alternative dispute resolution, Anderson Kill has substantial experience in construction litigations and arbitrations. Anderson Kill attorneys have successfully handled multi-week court trials and arbitration hearings, as well as both pre-trial and post-trial appeals. Anderson Kill’s lawyers have appeared in some of the highest level courts around the country.

Our attorneys have handled matters such as:

  • Defective materials used in construction
  • Faulty design or construction
  • Claims for “extra” work and scope changes
  • Disputes over contract terms
  • Change Orders
  • Delay claims
  • Indemnity claims
  • “Liquidating” or “Pass-Through” Agreements
  • Mechanics’ liens
  • Code disputes
  • Geotechnical issues
  • Bond disputes
  • Casualty loss
  • Construction trust disputes

Insurance Coverage Disputes

Anderson Kill has extensive experience in representing property owners, developers, contractors and other project participants, including design professionals, in securing insurance recoveries for property losses and in securing defense and indemnification for liability resulting from accidents and construction defects in connection with real estate development. The firm’s attorneys have represented clients seeking first-party insurance recoveries under builder’s risk and other types of coverages for losses ranging from natural disasters, the World Trade Center attack, power plant explosions, and the invasion of Panama, to run of the mill of water and fire damage losses. The firm also has represented owners/developers, contractors and other project participants seeking defense and indemnity for numerous types of third-party claims, including claims for wrongful death, bodily injuries and third-party property damages arising from construction accidents, claims for construction defects, including defective building materials and faulty workmanship, and other assertions. Anderson Kill regularly pursues such coverage not just under our clients’ own liability insurance program, whether that insurance is provided for in a wrap-up (i.e., OCIP or CCIP) or the client’s practice program, but also from insurance of others obligated to name our clients as additional insureds under their liability insurance coverage programs.

Our reputation as one of the top policyholder insurance recovery firms in the nation, combined with our experience in representing property owners/developers, contractors and others in construction disputes, often enables us to accelerate the resolution of insurance claims in the early stages of the claim, thus maximizing our clients’ recoveries. Our attorneys also have considerable experience in working with insurance consultants for owners, developers and contractors undertaking significant construction and renovation projects.

Construction, Development, Design and Planning

The firm offers a broad range of services to clients contemplating and undertaking construction and renovation projects. We have represented land owners, real estate developers, tenants, contractors, design professionals, financial services companies, investors, and lenders in numerous projects. The firm has had considerable experience with hospitals, schools, office buildings, residential apartments and condominiums, data centers, water treatment plants, and combined-use structures incorporating residential, retail and office towers.

Some of the areas in which we have assisted clients include:

  • Negotiation, drafting and amendment of numerous lump sum, guaranteed maximum price and variable price construction, construction management and architectural contracts, ranging from small retrofit projects to developments costing in excess of $500 million
  • Mechanic’s lien filing and release
  • Preventing, litigating and responding to claims relating to mechanic’s liens
  • Owner’s representative agreements
  • Retainage release issues
  • Asbestos and other hazardous waste issues
  • Advance payment procedures
  • Demolition contracts
  • Trade contractor bankruptcies
  • Payment workouts, including constructive trust issues
  • Design errors and omissions
  • Delay claims negotiation and litigation
  • Change order negotiations, including scope disputes
  • Coordination between adjoining landowners concerning access, and protection of property
  • Property damage claims
  • Warranty issues
  • Risk management policies and procedures
  • Punchlist administration issues
  • Claims against sureties under payment and performance bonds
  • Assisting clients in navigating the lien laws of the several states

 

Construction Regulatory & Government Strategy

Construction projects often involve far more than legal disputes. Delays, permitting issues, agency enforcement, regulatory changes, political considerations, and community concerns can significantly affect project schedules, costs, and outcomes.

Anderson Kill’s Government Relations team works alongside the firm’s Construction Group to help clients navigate matters involving the New York City Department of Buildings (DOB), FDNY, DEP, DOT, HPD, OATH, City Hall, the New York State Legislature, and other state and local agencies. Our team assists clients with regulatory strategy, permit and compliance issues, Stop Work Orders, agency investigations, legislative and regulatory advocacy, and other government-related matters that can impact construction and development projects.

The group is led by Brad Gerstman, Chair of Government Relations, and includes former New York City Buildings Commissioner Rick D. Chandler, whose decades of leadership and regulatory experience provide clients with valuable strategic insight into New York City’s construction and development environment. Together, they work closely with Anderson Kill’s construction litigators to provide coordinated legal, regulatory, and strategic guidance designed to help clients resolve challenges efficiently and keep projects moving forward.

Events

Matching Disputes in Property Insurance Claims

Barbri / July 23, 2026

Contractual Risk Transfer for the Construction Industry

DFW RIMS / March 18, 2026

The Construction and Insurance Conference

Anderson Kill / January 28, 2026

Construction Contracts 2026

National Business Institute / December 22, 2025

Risky Business: The Art of Drafting and Negotiating an Airtight Contract

ClaimsXchange Annual Conference 2025 / October 9, 2025

Advanced Construction Law 2025

NBI Webinar / August 21, 2025

The Top 6 Pain Points in Construction Contracts

National Business Institute / June 5, 2025

Advanced Construction Law

NBI Webinar / December 23, 2024

Maximizing Insurance Recovery for Liability and Defect Claims in Construction

Anderson Kill / November 28, 2023

INSURANCE COVERAGE ISSUES FOR POLICYHOLDERS INVOLVED IN CONSTRUCTION LITIGATION

2022 North American Construction Law Symposium IV / December 1, 2022

Construction OCIP-CCIP Insurance Programs: Potential Coverage Gaps and Other Coverage Pitfalls (2022)

Strafford Publications / September 27, 2022

Construction Litigation of Additional Insured Endorsements: Blanket Clause Risks, Contractual Privity, Coverage Limits

Strafford Publications / September 14, 2022

CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS, PROJECT MANAGEMENT, AND RISK MITIGATION: HOW TO MANAGE RISKS BEFORE, DURING, AND AFTER CONSTRUCTION THROUGH CONTRACT DRAFTING, PROJECT MANAGEMENT, AND INSURANCE

Strafford Publications / July 27, 2022

Important Coverage Issues Relating to Complex Construction Losses

First Party Claims Conference / October 19, 2016

Construction OCIP/CCIP Insurance Programs: Potential Coverage Gaps and Other Coverage Pitfalls

April 5, 2016

Publications

Don’t Assume: Indemnity and Additional Insured Coverage Are Not the Same

New York Law Journal / April 2, 2026

Essential Contract Considerations for Construction Projects in 2026

ENREast / February 11, 2026

Out With the Old: Time to Retire Outdated Construction Defects Insurance Law

New York Law Journal / February 3, 2026

How Should Construction Companies Handle DEI Under Trump?

Construction Dive / June 5, 2025

Protect Your Business Against New Tariffs on Construction Materials

Anderson Kill Construction Industry Alert / December 5, 2024

The Day The Digital Construction World Stood Still: Will the CrowdStrike Failure Trigger Force Majeure?

Construction Industry Advisor / August 5, 2024

New York State Updates Prompt Payment Act

Anderson Kill Construction Industry Advisor / March 15, 2024

Consider Self-Help to Trigger Additional-Insured Status

Law360 / July 12, 2023

A Defective Precedent for “Defective Work” in Insurance Coverage

New York Law Journal / May 22, 2023

Lessons From The Surfside Condo Collapse One Year Later

Risk Management Magazine / June 30, 2022

Transferring Risk With Contracts, Insurance Coverage And Sometimes, Litigation

New York Law Journal / December 10, 2021

A 10-POINT CHECKLIST FOR TRANSFERRING RISK

Construction Executive / May 7, 2021

Builders Risk Policies Cover COVID-19 Construction Losses

Law 360 / April 30, 2020

SECURING INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR CONSTRUCTION DEFECT CLAIMS

Construction Industry Advisor / July 1, 2004

News

Anderson Kill Attorneys Honored in The Best Lawyers in America 2027

August 20, 2026

Costly Contract Pitfalls Every Subcontractor Should Avoid: Podcast

July 31, 2025

Law360 Names Wolff to Construction Editorial Advisory Board

April 16, 2020

Allen R. Wolff of Anderson Kill Appointed to Law360’s Construction Editorial Advisory Board

April 16, 2020

Proper Insurance Coverage for Construction Crucial in Avoiding Costly Litigation

September 21, 2018

Atty’s Guide To Construction Professional Liability Coverage

May 14, 2018

10th Circ. Split Adds Wrinkle To NY Faulty Work Coverage Law

February 15, 2018

Insurance Industry Sees Challenges with New York City Crawler Crane Requirements

November 30, 2016

NY Additional-Insured Ruling Builds Doubt For Contractors

September 16, 2016

James P. Cullen to be Honored for Human Rights Work by Franciscan Friars

September 24, 2014

Anderson Kill Lures Construction Insurance Vet From Olshan

August 21, 2013

Allen R. Wolff Joins Anderson Kill as a Shareholder in New York

August 21, 2013

Anderson Kill Promotes Dennis J. Artese and Cort T. Malone to Shareholder

June 3, 2011

Maryland Circuit Court Affirms Performance Bond Obligation to First Baptist Church of Guilford and First Mariner Bank

May 23, 2011

People

image
Cameron R. Argetsinger

Shareholder , Washington, DC

image
image
Dennis J. Artese

Shareholder , New York

image
image
Jeffrey E. Glen

Of Counsel , New York

image
image
Jason Kosek

Shareholder , New York

image
image
Ethan W. Middlebrooks

Shareholder , New York

image
image
Allen R. Wolff

Shareholder , New York

image
Key Contact(s)
image
Dennis J. Artese
View Moreimage
image
Allen R. Wolff
View Moreimage

© Copyright 2026 by Anderson Kill P.C. ClickySoft - WordPress Development Company