Anderson Kill has been ranked a National Tier 1 firm in Insurance Litigation in Benchmark Litigation 2015. Benchmark also recognized Robert M. Horkovich and William G. Passannante, co-chairs of the firm's Insurance Recovery Group, as national litigation stars.

Benchmark also named Anderson Kill a recommended litigation firm in New York, recognizing Mr. Horkovich and Mr. Passannante as state litigation stars and Joshua Gold, chair of the firm's Cyber Insurance Recovery Group, as a future star.