image

Articles

When Sublimits Bite: Navigating Cyber Insurance Risks in Retail and Hospitality

Cyber Insurance Recovery Alert

  • Published On: May 13, 2026

The retail and hospitality industries are prime targets for cybercriminals due to high-volume transactions, sensitive customer data, and interconnected supply chains. Ransomware, phishing, malware, and credential theft are increasingly causing multimillion-dollar losses, operational disruption, supply chain instability, and reputational harm.

At the same time, many insurance companies are trying to channel cyber-related claims into “sub-limited” coverage clauses rather than paying under the full policy limits. These sublimits, often involving risks such as wire fraud, social engineering, ransomware, and “non-hacking” events, can be exploited in ways that exceed their intended scope. Insurance companies use sublimits in an attempt to restrict coverage, including by recharacterizing claims, applying sublimits as broad caps, or treating them as exclusive remedies. Even where coverage is otherwise clear, these tactics can reduce payouts, fueling a growing number of disputes over the proper application of sublimits. Recent federal court decisions underscore the importance of scrutinizing the increasing use of sublimits and understanding their impact on policyholder cyber protection.

Legal Pushback on Overly Restrictive Sublimits

On February 24, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas ruled in CiCi Enterprises LP v. HSB Specialty Insurance Co. that the cyber insurance company improperly applied a sublimit to greatly reduce payments for a malware loss.

CiCi suffered a malware attack, encrypting its systems and stealing data. The cyber insurance policy covered, among other things, “Cyber Extortion” up to $3 million. The cyber policy also included a $250,000 sub-limit coverage for something defined as a “Ransomware Event,” which purported to include any related Information Privacy Event, a related Network Security Event, and a related System Disruption. Overall, the policy contained seven Insuring Agreements for claims and loss from Information Privacy Liability; Network Security; Business Interruption; Cyber Extortion; Financial Fraud; Media Content; and Reputational Harm.

The cyber insurance company argued that its maximum payout for the malware claim was $250,000 rather than the $3 million promised for cyber extortion. The policyholder argued against application of the sublimit, and the federal court agreed “that CiCi’s interpretation of the Ransomware Sub-Limit Endorsement is supported by the Policy language and structure, that is, that the Endorsement is not applicable on its face to Insuring Agreement D. Cyber Extortion.”

The court ruled in CiCi’s favor after carefully scrutinizing HSB’s policy language, including the wording of other policy endorsements.  Notably, the court found that “notwithstanding HSB’s contentions that the ‘Policy’s intent is glaringly obvious’ and ‘clearly states that the Endorsement applies to all insuring agreements[,]’ the Endorsement lacks any explicit language specifying that it applies to all the Section I Insuring Agreements. Instead, the Ransomware Sub-Limit Endorsement states that it is ‘added to section II. Limits of Insurance’ without making any reference to modifying Section I. Insuring Agreements. Section II. Limits of Insurance, however, does not afford any coverage to CiCi, but merely establishes HSB’s maximum liability ‘with respect to the Insuring Agreement to which each such Sub-Limit of Insurance applies….’” The court further reasoned that the “Ransomware Sub-Limit Endorsement does not state that it modifies or alters coverage under Insuring Agreement D. Cyber Extortion.”

The court also noted that the Ransomware Sub-Limit Endorsement “does not even include the words ‘Cyber Extortion,’ or ‘Extortion Loss’ related to ‘Cyber Extortion.’ Instead, it states that ‘[a]ll other terms, conditions, and exclusions of the Policy shall remain unchanged.’”

The court also heeded the legal maxim that if words of limitation are to be applied to cut off coverage, the language must be express and clear: “If HSB wanted the $250,000 sub-limit to apply across the board, regardless of the Insuring Agreement, then it was incumbent upon HSB to expressly and clearly state that. Having not done so, it cannot now complain.”

And perhaps most importantly, the court also addressed the structure and definition of “Cyber Event” and “Ransomware Event” noting that “these two terms are distinct and separate types of events.” Specifically, ‘‘‘Ransomware Event’ was added as a type of ‘Cyber Event’ and joined the other types of ‘Cyber Event,’ including Information Privacy Event, Network Security Event, and Extortion Threat. Based on the amended definition of ‘Cyber Event,’ by its plain language, the court determines that the inclusion of ‘Ransomware Event’ was meant to be treated as a separate event from the other types of ‘Cyber Event,’ including being separate and distinct from an ‘Extortion Threat.’ As the drafter of the Endorsement, if HSB intended for ‘Ransomware Event’ as merely a subset of an ‘Extortion Threat,’ then it could have made that intent clear by stating so.”

Second Circuit Confirms Broad Coverage Beyond Sublimits

A similar pro-policyholder decision from the Second Circuit addressed a sublimit in a computer systems outage context. In Ariz. Beverages USA, LLC v. Hanover Ins. Co., no. 23-1177 (2d Cir.), the policyholder suffered a system outage causing loss of historical financial data.  The power surge also prevented the policyholder from accessing “its computer systems to see account balances, receivables, inventory, and order information.” The policyholder sought coverage under its property policy, including for audit expenses.  This in turn led to the bank demanding regular audits in order to keep the credit facility in place.  The policy had promised “Equipment Breakdown Coverage” which included protection for “Extra Expense”.  The property policy also covered “Data Restoration,” under a sub-limit, which the policy defined as the “necessary cost to research, replace[,] and restore lost ‘data.’”

The insurance company argued that it did not have to cover the increased accounting costs for the audit, as the sub-limited data restoration coverage was exhausted and the extra expense coverage was inapplicable. In a Summary Order dated September 2, 2025, the Second Circuit ruled that the policyholder was entitled to coverage for the audit expenses related to the loss of certain financial information that jeopardized a credit facility with its bank.  Similar to the CiCi decision, the panel decided that the insurance company’s argument was not supported by the plain language of the Extra Expense clause because the “provision does not tie the end of the restoration period to the repair, replacement, or rebuilding of ‘covered equipment.’”

The court also rejected the claim that audit expenses were limited to the sub-limited data restoration clause, noting the Extra Expense provision could cover damages not explicitly mentioned elsewhere in the policy.

These two decisions demonstrate that policyholders should take insurance company arguments over the application of sub-limits skeptically.

Insurance Company’s Sometimes Succeed in Using Sublimits to Reduce Expected Payouts

In contrast to the two policyholder favorable decisions above, in Perry & Perry Builders Inc. v. Cowbell Cyber Inc., 2026 WL  673558 (W.D. Tex. Mar. 9. 2026), the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas delivered a cautionary decision for policyholders navigating cyber insurance claims. This case illustrates how sublimits can cap recovery for social engineering where coverage is undisputed.

The dispute arose after Perry & Perry Builders, Inc. (“Perry”) wired $874,000 in two separate payments to a fraudulent account after receiving a request for request for wire payment from a cybercriminal impersonating one of Perry’s vendors. Believing it was paying its steel vendor, Perry wired the money as two separate payments corresponding to two outstanding invoices. The insurance companies acknowledged coverage but applied a $250,000 sublimit, prompting litigation over whether each payment counted as a separate claim.

Although the insurance companies did not dispute that the loss fell within Perry’s cyber insurance policy’s coverage, they only paid Perry $250,000, arguing that recovery was capped by a $250,000 sublimit for social engineering fraud.  Perry sued on the basis that it was entitled to an additional $250,000 because each wire transfer represented a separate “claim.”  Accordingly, Perry argued that it was entitled to recover the $250,000 per claim sublimit twice – once for each separate transfer.

The court rejected Perry’s argument, finding that Perry acted volitionally in separating the payments into two separate transfers, made one minute apart, and refused to allow what it characterized as Perry’s “booking choices” to dictate the number of claims.  Instead, the court concluded that an endorsement in the policy capped the limit of liability at $250,000 for all Perry’s cyber losses during the policy period regardless of the number and value of each such loss.

In so ruling, the court did not find ambiguity in the terms of the policy sufficient to justify a reading in favor of additional coverage. Rather, it concluded that the policy, when read as a whole, supported the insurance companies’ interpretation that the sublimit functioned as a single aggregate cap for the type of loss at issue. As such, the court ruled in favor of the insurance companies, finding that they owed no further obligations to Perry.

Strategies for Policyholders Navigating Sublimits

As the frequency and severity of cyber-related losses continue to grow, policyholders should expect insurance companies to adopt increasingly aggressive defenses to reduce their liability.  This includes the practice of recharacterizing claims as falling within sublimited coverage grants in order to pay only a fraction of the policy’s overall limit.

For policyholders, the implications of these decisions are significant:

  • First, coverage alone is not enough. Even where a loss clearly falls within the scope of a policy, insurance companies may attempt to use other policy provisions, such as sublimits, to reduce a policyholder’s actual recovery.
  • Second, policyholders must understand how insurance companies may use sublimits to try and reduce their payments on covered claims. Sublimits are frequently embedded in endorsements addressing specific risks.
  • Third, how a loss is characterized is critically important to coverage. Cyber-related losses frequently implicate multiple insuring agreements, and insurance companies may seek to characterize a claim in a manner that confines it to the most restrictive coverage grant – often one subject to a much lower sublimit than the policy’s overall limit.

Policyholders should carefully consider the full scope of coverage available under their policies, including the various insuring agreements that may apply to a given loss. Rather than accepting an insurer’s characterization of a claim as falling within a narrow, sublimited provision, policyholders should evaluate whether broader coverage grants are implicated. As disputes over sublimits continue to evolve, a comprehensive and strategic approach to coverage—grounded in the policy’s language and structure—remains essential to ensuring that the protection purchased is the protection ultimately received.

Policyholders with questions regarding the application of sublimits or the scope of their insurance coverage for cyber-related losses should consider consulting experienced coverage counsel.

 

Related People
image
Luma S. Al-Shibib
View Moreimage
image
Joshua Gold
View Moreimage
image
Difie M. Osborne
View Moreimage

© Copyright 2026 by Anderson Kill P.C.